Vacation rentals in Cassadaga

Forest Retreat, 90 miles to Niagara Falls.

Welcome to Forest Retreat! We are nestled in the hills of Western New York, 23 miles to Chautauqua Lake and 14 miles to Lily Dale. This unique home is near several wedding venues and the Earl Cardot Overland Trail, which is surrounded by 2,300 acres of state forest. We are located between 2 local ski resorts, and only 87 miles south of Niagara Falls State park. Relax by the fire, kayak, or fish in the 2 acre pond and just enjoy the scenery. We do require a signed waiver to utilize the pond.

The Lodge in Cassadaga

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. This cozy rustic cottage is tucked away in the woods while still being close to many local attractions. You’ll be just 25 minutes away from Chautauqua Lake, The Chautauqua Institution, and Jamestown, 15 minutes from Lake Erie, and minutes away from Casssadaga public beach and boat launch, as well as Lily Dale. If you’re up for a day trip, Buffalo and Niagara Falls are within a couple hours. Come relax and enjoy a peaceful stay in the woods!

Lakefront Sunset Getaway on Cassadaga Lake

Welcome to the Cottage! This cottage sits directly on Cassadaga Lake where you can enjoy beautiful sunsets every night from the concrete patio or from the couch. Feel free to go kayaking, fishing, or swimming directly from the dock or shoreline. Perfect for anyone who wants to enjoy lake life for the weekend, week, or month! *NEW* 2 kayaks are available for free use during your stay. No gatherings, events, and/or parties larger than your reservation. Free parking up to 2 cars.

Kingfisher Point: Beautiful New Lakeside Home

This stylish new lake house was completed in September of 2022, and we are excited to open it to visitors to the Cassadaga Lake. Our home on Cassadaga Lake rests among the trees of an old growth forest adjacent to protected wetlands. Guests can enjoy the sun setting over the lake each evening from one of two porches facing the lake, or from the kayaks that are available to guests. And yes, Kingfishers are frequent visitors to the lakes as well! (No smoking and no pets allowed).

Blue Canoe/Upscale Lake Cottage/Chautauqua

Welcome to Blue Canoe Lake Cottage on Cassadaga Lakes! This small, 2 Queen Bedroom/1 Full Bath, newly renovated, open-concept, light-filled cottage offers 125 ft of private waterfront, a gated covered porch, & thoughtful details throughout. Enjoy 2 kayaks, 2 paddle boards, a pedal boat, 4 adult cruiser bikes, fire pit, & propane grill. Dog-friendly & perfect for up to 4 adults — luxury on the lake awaits! If booked, check out our sister property, Blue Oar (4BR/3BA, lakefront!

Crossroads-A hidden gem.

Crossroads, a historic home constructed in 1852, was one of the original stops on the Underground Railroad. It is included in the Historic Walking Tour of Cassadaga. Barry and Gayle acquired the property in 1989. In 2016, a substantial restoration project was undertaken to enhance the farmhouse. Crossroads is a hidden gem, located at the intersection of Glasgow Road, Dale Drive, and Frisbee Road. The property provides access to a wide variety of attractions and experiences.

Charming townhouse in Fredonia

Bring the whole family! Location & Comfort! Newly renovated, furnished & decorated townhouse-up to 8 guests w/ all the modern conveniences. This ideal location is only a 5 min drive from downtown Fredonia! Fully furnished w/ total of 3 bedrooms & 2 bathrooms. 1st floor: kitchen & dining, living room, full bathroom complete with washer/dryer, guest bedroom 1 (queen) , sunroom/patio with sleeper sofa 2nd floor: full bathroom, guest bedroom 2(full), guest bedroom3 (king)

Spacious Apartment in Historic Fredonia

This 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath apartment has a fully equipped kitchen; master suite with whirlpool tub; laundry, living, & dining rooms; & study. Attached to an historic home with on-site parking and private entrances, it has a porch overlooking a tree-shaded lot & quiet street. A 5-minute walk from SUNY Fredonia & downtown Fredonia, 3 miles from Lake Erie; a 35-minute drive from the Chautauqua Institute; & 1 hour from Niagara Falls, casinos, & ski resorts.

Cozy Comfort at Cassadaga Lake

Come fish, swim, kayak, walk around the beautiful lake.Snowmobile in winter. this cozy has access for canoes and kayaks across the street at Cassadaga Creek that connects with Cassadaga lake which is just a short distance of rowing. one mile from Lilly Dale. access to snowmobile trails less than one mile from house Would not consider this as a destination vacation but a nice place to stay with activities in surrounding areas.

Island Cabin - The Paddle Inn

Abundant privacy is yours at this Island paradise on beautiful Cassadaga Lakes. Accessible by an arched bridge or boat, the cottage is brand new inside and out, is environmentally friendly, provides endless outdoor adventure and a charming interior. Fish from the back deck, swim in crystal clear lake water, relax on the covered porch, and enjoy boundless nature literally at your fingertips, in this very unique setting.

Lily Dale Sanctuary! KING APARTMENT, We ❤️ Pets

Lily Dale Sanctuary! Private, Spacious, Pet-friendly Suite: KING bed, living room, bedroom w/en-suite bathroom. A/C, WiFi, Kayak, Bonus outdoor seating area. Asian-styled apartment on ground level of Victorian home w/incredible history. Susan B. Anthony stayed in this home when she visited Lily Dale. No stairs to climb! ** ONE PET MAXIMUM ** ***Guests must adhere to NY guidelines on COVID travel restrictions.***

Peace, love and a tiny cabin

ONE PERSON ONLY Awesome getaway. Close to Lily Dale 420 friendly . For the minimalist traveler Non electric, off the grid cabin A welcoming haven away from the hectic world ! Access to hot tub Access to bathroom with flush toilet Access to hot shower Communal living Tiny cabin Twin size bed Minimalist stay Family friendly camp Great hosts and amazing country location No smoking or vaping inside No pets