Vacation rentals in Castle Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Castle Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favourite

Cottage in Thornville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 416 reviews

Little House on main lake of Buckeye Lake

The Little House on Buckeye Lake, sits on the main lake and is the perfect place to get away from the day to day stress, relax and enjoy lake life at its best! Private setting. Central air-conditioning for those hot summer nights. Gas grill (May 1st-Nov 1st) Plenty of parking. Firepit on site ,firewood not provided Boat dock. Bring your poles for fishing out the back door. Close to Legend Valley, Winery, The Port, Horvath Harbor, National Trails, Interstate 70 NO ADDITIONAL GUESTS OR VISITORS

May 31 – Jun. 7

$373 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Home in Newark

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

The Oak Ridge House

Welcome to the Oak Ridge House. Just 5 miles North of I-70 and 5 miles south of State Rt.16. Our tree cover hillside is very close to Flint Ridge Nature Preserve and about 15 minutes from The Virtues Golf Club, Black Hand Gorge Nature Preserve and Sand Hollow Winery. It's a three bedroom home on 2 acres, one king size bed, one queen size bed, and the third room is a sitting room / hang out space with a futton. The enclose back porch is a great hangout space but is not heated. Gov. ID required.

Oct. 4 – 11

$141 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 244 reviews

3 Bedroom 2 Bath Cottage

Intel Amazon. 30 min E of Cbus. 1 mile off I 79. Walk to all of Buckeye Lake’s best!Buckeye lake Bike path, Boat Chef Shack, Brewery, Restaurants, Entertainment, Museum Pizza, Shopping., Boatyard, and on and on!! No railing to the the OH State creek in back may not be suitable for children. Roomy and Private Fire Pit Granville,Newark, Hebron,Heath, Lancaster, Columbus, Legend Valley, National Trail, Midland, Denison, OSU, Amazon Etna, Hocking Hill, Winery, Zanesville Intel within 30 min. .

May 16 – 23

$189 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Cottage in Granville

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Timbuk Ridge, Granville Ohio.

Unwind at this private, peaceful countryside property. Located in the beautiful rolling hills just ten minutes north from the quaint village of Granville and Denison University. Relax at this unique bungalow style home tucked on 11 wooded acres. Enjoy the first floor chefs kitchen, second floor eclectic loft style interior design, queen size bed, sitting area, bathroom w/steam shower. Seasonally available screened porch and outdoor patio. Message for elopement/additional guest options.

Jun. 11 – 18

$221 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Cottage in Thornville

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Buckeye Lake Retreat

A great place for families and fishermen Beautiful home right on the channel and direct access to the lake. Excellent for fishing, catching catfish right from the dock. It's an excellent place to relax and unwind. Fish directly off the dock or use the Kayaks included to explore the lake. We have an extra-long dock that can accommodate your boat(s). Fully equipped kitchen, your own washer and dryer, and a gas grill. There is a fire pit for the nights you want a campfire.

Feb. 14 – 21

$205 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Home in Lancaster

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 343 reviews

Lancaster Luxury Apartment

Your own private entrance, off street parking spot, kitchen, bathroom, dinning area, laundry, and furnished patio. Additional person and extra bed charge at $10 a night per guest with a maximum of four guests. We accept dogs for an additional $25 per stay fee but they must be crated when left alone in the apartment. We do not charge a cleaning fee :-) Minutes from everything Lancaster--bike path, Mt. Pleasant, the downtown historic district, restaurants, and museums.

Mar. 29 – Apr. 5

$155 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Cabin in Nelsonville

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 846 reviews

Getaway Hocking Hills - Columbus

An easy drive from the city, Getaway is a new way to experience the great outdoors. Nestled across dozens of acres of private woodlands, our modern, tiny cabins have everything you need (comfy bed, bathroom, fresh linens) and nothing you don’t. Featuring a private outdoor area (hello, fire pit), each cabin is designed to help you relax, unwind and disconnect from the everyday. Plus, as part of your stay, you'll receive firewood, a s'mores kit, coffee and bottled water*.

Aug. 19 – 26

$217 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Cabin in Newark

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Cozy Rustic Log Cabin on 22 acres with a creek

Relax in the woods in this rustic Log Cabin situated on 22 acres with a creek. Guests have access to all 22 acres. Memory Foam King sized bed, and pull out sofa for extra guests. Deer and other wildlife are in abundance. Cabin is fully furnished with Stainless gas stove, Stainless refrigerator , shower, smart TV (we do not have cable, but you may connect to your cellular device ex Netflix/YouTube) Wi-Fi, microwave, coffee pot, firepit, and other necessities. 🪵 🔥 🦌 🍃

Jul. 1 – 8

$153 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Cottage in Lancaster

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Cheerful 1-bedroom cottage with indoor fireplace

Welcome travelers to the Rockmill Cottage! This bright, one bedroom guesthouse is located across the street from the historic mill and a short drive to restaurants, grocers, shops, and breweries. Enjoy the craftsman woodwork throughout, including a gas fireplace, fully appointed kitchen and cozy loft. In warmer months, the outdoor gazebo is perfect for morning coffee or a picnic. Please note that the cottage is on the same property as the Rockmill Farmhouse.

Nov. 29 – Dec. 6

$187 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Cabin in Zanesville

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 535 reviews

Unique Kabin in the Woods

We are situated near I-70 and, Dillon State Park, Blackhand Gorge and The Wilds. Bald Eagle, Deer, Turkey, Rabbit, Squirrels are in the area.There's golf, wineries and breweries nearby. You'll love the coziness and privacy of the place. This place is good for couples, families, solo adventurers and business travelers. If you choose to stay a few nights longer, make a request to ABNB at least 6 hours in advance. To be sure it is completed. Thanks Mark

Oct. 2 – 9

$193 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Granville

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 417 reviews

Yellow Bird Guest House, Hosts: Mindy and Bob

Free standing cottage, private, quiet, off street parking. Easy walk to grocery store, university, restaurants, shopping and museums. We also enjoy giving eco-tours of our organic gardens and orchard. Learn about raising backyard chickens. Quilters often enjoy trying their hand at Long-Arm machine quilting in Mindy's textile studio. Or ask to watch Bob in his woodworking shop as he fashions custom Singer Featherweight drop in sewing tables.

Oct. 11 – 18

$139 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Cabin in Glenford

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 416 reviews

Hopewell Springs Farm and Racquet(ish) Club

a secluded hilltop retreat on 5 woodsy, landscaped acres; wood stove for cold-weather fires; large deck with gas grill; x-treme tennis court* with pavilion and fire ring; walking trails, many also suitable for cross-country-skiing**; well-behaved pets negotiable note: parties and events are not allowed * cracked surface adds a challenge (think Wimbledon meets Whack-a-Mole) ** (and, if you take certain trails, downhill skiing)

Mar. 25 – Apr. 1

$253 CAD per night