Private suite vacation rentals in Fire Island

Relatives were in town for a family event and we arranged their stay at Cupola Hill. Their feedback: "We really enjoyed our stay at Cupola Hill. It is just as nice as advertised. The hosts were great about dealing with winter storm conditions. They kept the snow and the ice under control during our stay including getting the driveway plowed after a 5 inch snowstorm early Sunday morning. The unit was clean and comfortable in every way. The shower was great!! We would love to go back. Five stars.”

Jennifer was a great host, and the appartment was well equipped and fantastic to chill out at for a few days. The balcony was great to sit out in the sunshine and the beach and restaurants were all in easy walking distance. I would not hesitate to go back should my travels take me back to New York.

Had a wonderful time at Sandy’s casita. Such a gem of a place, it had everything I could need for a 5-day stay. I cooked at least once a day and the kitchen was perfectly stocked. Beautiful interior, comfortable, clean, and so cool. Sandy is an excellent host! I hope to come back one day.

we stayed for valentines weekend, Lori was a great host. we had a problem with the bed frame falling apart and Lori was quick to rectify. the fridge had some extra food and water bottles which makes up for only having a hot plate to cook. overall great host and a good stay.

Alexis was very good at responding to questions. Place was clean and shower was hot. A must for me! Highly recommend their place.

The home was absolutely gorgeous and peaceful. It's exactly as described but even more spacious than I expected. They put a lot into making guests feel welcome, including prompt communication, a quick walk through to explain where things are, numerous suggestions for the surrounding area, and even a tray of welcome cookies! I came for a 50k trail race, so the hot tub was a perfect added bonus. I HIGHLY suggest booking this property, and I'll definitely be back to spend some time at the beach.

Yinka’s unit was clean, comfortable, and in a perfect location for getting to the city while being in a quiet and safe neighborhood with easy access to the rest of Long Island. The train station’s very walkable. The unit was well equipped with anything you’d need during a stay (TV, toiletries, linens, fridge, microwave, etc). Yinka is so friendly and sweet. I appreciate how proactive she was about checking in to see if we needed anything. Great value. Highly recommend staying here!

Another wonderful stay. Thank you Michael!

Jackie is so sweet and was so responsive! I will be staying here again!

Kayla’s place was great! Amenities are unmatched. The gym was really cool, the movie theater was fun and that sauna was very relaxing! We had a few issues with the heat that Kayla controls from her phone, but she was very responsive and easy to communicate with working to resolve it. Check in and out was easy. We ordered in most nights and the uber delivery didn’t take long to get out there. Overall I’d recommend this place!

Joy and Ronnie were so kind and accommodating. They helped me with my mountain of luggage as i was traveling cross country. They helped me feel so comfortable, i barely realized I was not renting an entire place to myself. Beautiful place, awesome hosts. I'd stay again!

Linda was very responsive and the place is immaculate inside. Very nice furnishings and spacious parking for 2 vehicles.

The host was wonderful and very friendly. The directions were excellent and the room was comfortable, spacious and clean-plus there were a number of amenities, including a Keurig coffee machine, snacks and water. A great stay and I will definitely be back when I’m in the area again! Not to be missed!

Wonderful neighborhood. Peaceful,quiet and always felt safe. Friendly host- a pleasure to speak with. Beautifully appointed space- king bed, beautiful bathroom- felt like home!

We loved staying at Justin and Mihos place. The atmosphere is peaceful ☺️ the farm is delightful and we had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. The photos do not do this fantastic Airbnb justice. It’s spacious, clean the kitchen well outfitted and Justin and Miho are so helpful and responsive . We will be staying again very soon and can’t wait.

this was perfect for my trip. close to some essential locations. the home is very well kept. only note for any plus sized travelers is the shower stall might be a tight fit. if i find myself back in amityville i’ll definitely book here again.

Thank you Ysancis for hosting my family and I. We had a lovely time and the place was comfortable. The host has gone above and beyond to provide amenities one wouldn’t have expected. Will definitely stay again.

My family (2 adults, 2 small children) felt right at home and had everything we needed. This was the perfect private oasis during a busy weekend, and the spaces were very clean, well-maintained, roomy, and in short felt like being at home. Thank you!

This was an amazing rental, the host was amazing from beginning to end. Me and my family felt right at home. TBH this was actually my best rental stay out of all the air bnb’s I’ve stayed in. The home was very warming and welcoming. The host left goodies and breakfast for me and my family and all needs were met to the T. Normally my family and I go out to eat and do activities but this stay was way different. It felt like a home away from home and the time spent was relaxing and I just cooked in. My daughter loved the bed and said it felt better than hers lol. The kitchen was great and the bathroom was also very nice. To anyone looking to stay in this area I would recommend this location top tier. If I could rate higher than 5 I would have as well. Thank you so much for all that you guys did and thank you for allowing me and my family into your space.

"The flat is wonderful, just the same and even better than in the photos, super clean and organized, check in and check out without bureaucracy the location is more than perfect, near the beach. The hostess Mougeh is grade 1000!!! Always very friendly and attentive, answers all questions quickly! I loved the stay in the city of Milford, I will come back more often for sure!".

Marc’s place was very clean. Despite being an upper level of a multi-level home, there was no noise from downstairs. The neighborhood was quiet. Despite it being all street parking, we were able to park our big rental SUV very close to the apartment each day.

Louis's place was fantastic! I can't say enough good things about my stay! I wasn't familiar with the area at all and I debated btwn an air bnb or hotel. Thankfully, I made the right choice!! He accommodated last minute requests I had quickly, easing my stress. It really is the perfect hideaway..quiet, peaceful, VERY private and safe feeling. Everything from kitchen to linens to bathroom was spotless! Big and comfy bed..Modern and pristine appliances, and everything that I needed for a quiet dinner in, down to the slightest detail. The rain-like shower felt amazing..so relaxing..like a scalp massage! Spacious and modern, yet very cozy place! The patio and fire area also is great for a private lounge outside. It felt like much thought and caring went into designing this beautiful space and I thoroughly enjoyed it! If I find myself in the area again, I'd definitely want to stay here! Thank you, Louis!

Quaint little apartment attached to a ranch house, leading right out to the back pool and hot tub and enough space inside to spread out a little. It was a solid choice for a long weekend, just a short distance from town. The beach pass is a nice perk.

I had a wonderful stay at this peaceful Airbnb in New York. The space was exactly as described—clean, quiet, and comfortable. The host was incredibly helpful and responsive, making check-in and communication easy. Plus, the location was perfect—close to shops, restaurants, and public transit. Highly recommend!