Smoking-friendly vacation rentals in Fire Island

If Gina's listing had just lived up to the description, this would have been a great experience. However, not only did it live up to the description, I cannot say enough about how wonderful Gina was to communicate with. She was unbelievably responsive, caring, empathetic, flexible, accommodating, and overall was just really committed to ensuring that my stay was the best it possibly could be. The personal touch that Gina put on the experience and the way that she made me feel at home was above and beyond what I could have hoped for. If you're looking to stay in the area and value having a host who truly cares about making your stay as comfortable and easy as possible, look no further than booking with Gina.

Maureen’s place is super clean! The space was just perfect. Close walk to beach and restaurants. Maureen is very accommodating and makes sure you have everything you need. We will be going back!

I was VERY EXCITED with my stay and would stay again and would tell everyone about my AMAZING AND WONDERFUL stay. I couldn’t have asked for a more beautiful and fulfilling stay. I felt like I was home away from home. Allison was very, extremely helpful with making sure that we felt comfortable and had everything we needed. She went above and beyond making sure that everything was taken care of if needed. I couldn’t have asked for anything more. She’s a fantastic host.

Great location and great host!

Liam was incredibly quick to respond and accommodating to our group’s last minute booking. The location is excellent and great for having a car or taking a train. Great, quiet “, comfy spot and had everything we needed and a great value for the area.

Thank you very much for providing me with incredible days at your house, I really felt at home!!!

A great area to stay at. Lots of things close by if you needed something. Short drive to New York. Debbie gave great instructions on how to get to the cottage house and checked on us a few times to make sure everything was going fine. The snow was beautiful in the yard and our dogs loved it since we are from the south and rarely get snow. Would definitely stay here again if we ever decided to come back this way.

This house was absolutely stunning! The views were breathtaking! The host was friendly, helpful, and polite. The kitchen was completely stacked as well! It had all types of spices, dishes, and appliances. If you need it, they’ll have it! Having this house as our base for a weekend of winery hoping was wonderful, and made it even more special and enjoyable! 10/10 would totally recommend!

Three generations of my family were comfortable sharing Jessica's house. The children and their parents slept upstairs, while the grandparents had the downstairs to ourselves. It was a perfect arrangement for getting a good night's sleep. The house is well organized and comfortable, with plenty of kitchen supplies for cooking, and has a pleasant porch for outside lounging. It is walking distance to a beach on the bay - a safer beach for small children than the ocean. All and all, a good experience!

Very comfortable older home. Understand that this is the owner's actually home, not a typical airbnb rental. As part of the arrangement, we took care of Emily's two cats while she was away; the kitties are friendly and pretty much independent (feed them dry food, fill water, clean the litter); they'll hang out and sit next to you on the couch in the evening. If you're not into kitties, just don't stay here. My granddaughter got to play with Emily's son's toys. I made use of the kitchen to bake pies for our family holiday gathering. Did not get to use the grounds (porch or yard), bc it was frigid cold this December. We all enjoyed the lovely Christmas tree set up in the living room. Emily was flexible about check-in/checkout times too. Thank you, Emily. >^..^<

This is a perfect spot in a magical place. Honestly the photos don’t do it justice. The views from the house are stunning. The deck is incredible and I loved listening to ocean waves all day and night. My friends and I had a great time. Will definitely be back! Thanks again.

This house was awesome, it’s located in a quiet residential area but only a quick 10 minute drive to town. We had a group of 12 people and we slept very comfortably. Check in/check out was super easy, the house was furnished very well, and it came with all the essentials we needed. Cooked at the house and had all the cookware/utensils that you can think of. House was clean and the host was very friendly! Would definitely recommend staying here.

Love this place: history, mystique, comfort, unpretentious/rustic yet with great WiFi. Rambling, picture-book old house/farm with history intact, rare big stretch of land on the water with charming scenes in every direction. Rolling grounds, vegetable/herb garden. Best vibe/sense of culture, art, books, board games, a kitchen for cooking big meals, views on all sides from all rooms, walks by the bay a few yards away and around the estate's hidden paths. Very generous, attentive, laid back hosts. Ideally set up for groups, with two spacious sea-view living rooms and bedrooms spaced apart, plus wood-burning fireplace with tons of wood stacked. Perfect in December when we stayed and must be magical in warmer weather. Very near villages with chic shops/restaurants etc. Would not change a single thing. Will definitely return if it's ever available in any season.

This place was perfect to execute my daughter’s surprise sleepover. The house was just as described in the listing. Very clean and spacious and had everything we needed to make our stay great. I would definitely recommend to others. Although, I had no issues with the house itself. I will advise to others to be cautious as to where you park, if you need to park on the street. Neighbors are disgustingly rude and will give you a hard time if you park in front of their house and yes, it is a PUBLIC street. Apparently, from what I heard the entire block is like this and they will not hesitate to call the cops if you take “their spot”. Other than that I had no issues whatsoever with my stay, my daughter and her besties loved the house and wished they could of stayed for 20 days more lol 🙂

Aleksandr was an extremely welcoming host. Her place was great, close to transportation to the city center, very quiet and clean. Thanks for everything, we had a wonderful weekend in New York.

Great hospitality and communication was excellent. View of the water and lots of space. Could also park right out front, vet accommodating and friendly.

Lee was an amazing host. He communicated well, provided a beautiful and clean space, and even got me an umbrella when it was raining out. I felt right at home. Walking to subway was easy and it truly was a peaceful and quiet space. Would recommend!

We were so fortunate to find Eleonora's listing. This was the perfect home base to visit some family in Brooklyn. The space was impressively big and the backyard was fantastic!