Guesthouse vacation rentals in Fire Island

Find and book unique guesthouse rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated guesthouses in Fire Island

Guests agree: these guesthouses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Stonington

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 223 reviews

True Artist Loft, 5 minutes to downtown Mystic

The Dacha, as it has lovingly been called for almost 80 years was built in 1945 originally as a studio for the artist that resided on the property. The unique structure is truly one of a kind, fully insulated for winter and tucked away from the road, sitting on a quiet piece of land, just 5 minutes to downtown Mystic. Enjoy modern comforts and a designers decor, while settling in front of the fire, or taking a short drive to all that Mystic has to offer- hiking, water, shops and restaurants.

Aug. 4 – 11

$348 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Oyster Bay

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

GORGEOUS & SERENE in Oyster Bay - LI/NY

Our small, modern bungalow is completely private. Perfect for working as it is for a romance, or just coming to LI-NY for the weekend. The luxurious queen bed is great, alone, or shared, and the custom sofa converts into another bed or two in a pinch (ask us about this before booking, it's got its limits); keep in mind that this is an open loft-like space. We're located on Long Island's North Shore, close to beaches yet only 45-minutes from Manhattan, and less than an-hour to The Hampton's.

Dec. 14 – 21

$393 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Southbury

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 266 reviews

Charming Guest Cottage with Modern Amenities

Private Guest House set on 5+ Acres, along with Historic Colonial Home. Bright and sunny and over looks pool and gardens (seasonal). Efficiency with Kitchen featuring 2 burner stove, Microwave, Under Counter Fridge/Freezer/Ice Maker, Dishwasher, Granite Counters. . Dining Area, Great Room w/ soaring ceilings, French Doors to private patio, hardwood floors. Loft with full-sized bed, and sofa can be a to Queen Size Sleeper. Full bath with extra-large shower. Dog friendly (approval needed).

Jun. 12 – 19

$248 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Hampton Bays

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

WELCOME TO THE LOVE SHACK BY THE SEA

Escape the city, work in nature! Totally private cottage with garden views , central air and heated floors. 1 mile from pristine beaches and center of town, LIRR, Hampton Jitney, 3 large grocery stores, Starbucks, organic market, shopping & restaurants. King bed, cable TV, refrigerator w/ice, microwave, outdoor grill, private yard, Perfect for couples, solo, 1-2 small kids. We welcome small dogs for a $100 fee. Please message us with the size and type. Working couple/owners in main house.

May 1 – 8

$504 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Norwalk

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

Adorable one-bedroom guesthouse with parking

Private, peaceful, cozy renovated cottage next to my house in a quiet residential neighborhood. Originally used as a painting and design studio, ideal for short stays and as a workspace. Luxury queen bed in upstairs loft; downstairs with refrigerator/freezer, Keurig with coffee and tea; microwave; Wifi, heat, air conditioning. There is NO RUNNING WATER in the cottage, but a lovely PRIVATE FULL BATH is just steps away in the main house AVAILABLE 24/7 exclusively for you during your stay.

Nov. 25 – Dec. 2

$199 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Norwalk

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Private one bedroom cottage on Conn. seashore

Enjoy time at this lovely studio located in the heart of Rowayton, a charming New England seaside village bounded on one side by Long Island sound and the other by a tidal inlet. Based in the southwest corner of CT, we are just a 1 minute walk to 2 separate and secluded beaches as well as 2 private, well manicured parks. Great amenities in town including tennis, sailing, outdoor yoga, sunbathing, plus nice restaurants. Pedestrian friendly town; you don't even need a car while here.

Jul. 11 – 16

$550 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in New Haven

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 241 reviews

Square 6ix

Inviting, eclectic, and completely private, this single family stand-alone guest house is an intimate and engaging haven. Stylishly decorated with mid-century modern furniture and adorned with pieces from local artists, this quiet home has a separate entrance, separate porch, high ceilings, and a fully equipped kitchen. The guest house is located a walking-block away from the charms of Westville Village and Edgewood Park.

Jun. 16 – 23

$289 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Mahopac

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Sunny Lakeview Guesthouse

Art and light filled spacious studio with panoramic views overlooking lake Mahopac. Walkable to swimming/paddleboarding; skating/ice fishing. Many fine restaurants or casual takeout options, and boasting an excellent coffee shop. Train ride from Grand Central to Croton Falls, then a 12 minute drive or shuttle ride. Close to Fahenstock Park, Cold Springs, Beacon, Ridgefield,or walk up the hill to the trails of Volz park

Dec. 21 – 28

$194 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Mystic

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 541 reviews

Gorgeous Waterfront Getaway

Perfect getaway from the city for couples wanting peace and tranquility and stunning views. A beautiful waterfront one bedroom guesthouse, one and one-half miles from downtown Mystic CT. Beautifully decorated with art and antiques. Kitchenette, full bath and loft bedroom. Queen bed. Air conditioning and heated. Belgian linen bedding! Private patio. Dock. Kayak/Canoe rentals close by. Internet.

Jan. 7 – 12

$298 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Peekskill

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 208 reviews

Peekskill Carriage House Downtown Studio

Located close to the center of town, this is the perfect launchpad to experience local restaurants, coffee houses, the Paramount Theater, shopping, etc. and a short drive to stunning hikes, the Hudson Valley and beyond. The apartment is ideal for one or two and features a kitchenette, bathroom, dining island, comfortable queen bed, and couch. peekskillcarriagehouse.com

Jul. 5 – 12

$209 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Brookhaven

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 215 reviews

The Unhampton

This Brookhaven Hamlet detached space (totally separate) is for people who love nature and preserved quiet spaces. Fire Island is a ferry ride away, Manhattan is one hour by train and the Hamptons are a 25 minute ride.15 minutes from the restaurants and coffee shops in Patchogue and just a couple of minutes from Bellport Village. Centrally located and truly peaceful!

Mar. 21 – 28

$239 CAD per night

Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Sayville

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 184 reviews

Great South Bay Cottage

Fantastic private cottage on Long Island's South Shore. Great access to the best beaches in the world (walk to bay, ferries to ocean). Short train ride to/from NYC, Wineries & The Hampton's. Experience the Island’s charm and culture. Enjoy Long Island summers. We are COVID conscious and employ a professional cleaning regiment.

Jan. 16 – 23

$287 CAD per night