Guesthouse vacation rentals in Fire Island

Find and book unique guesthouse rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated guesthouses in Fire Island

Guests agree: these guesthouses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favourite
A private outdoor space is showcased with a wooden deck, featuring two lounge chairs and a dining table shaded by an umbrella. Potted flowers add color, while a path leads through the well-maintained garden, enhancing the serene atmosphere of the yard.
Guesthouse in The Hamptons
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

WELCOME TO THE LOVE SHACK BY THE SEA

Escape the city, work in nature! Totally private cottage with garden views , central air and heated floors. 1 mile from pristine beaches and center of town, LIRR, Hampton Jitney, 3 large grocery stores, Starbucks, organic market, shopping & restaurants. King bed, cable TV, refrigerator w/ice, microwave, outdoor grill, private yard, Perfect for couples, solo, 1-2 small kids. We welcome small dogs for a $100 fee. Please message us with the size and type. Working couple/owners in main house.

Top guest favourite
A modest wooden house features large glass doors that lead to a spacious deck. The surrounding green lawn is complemented by well-kept shrubs and trees. Sunlight casts a warm glow on the exterior, highlighting the structure's simple charm.
Guesthouse in Rowayton
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews

1BR full cottage, 1 min walk to private beach

Enjoy time at this lovely studio located in the heart of Rowayton, a charming New England seaside village bounded on one side by Long Island sound and the other by a tidal inlet. Based in the southwest corner of CT, we are just a 1 minute walk to 2 separate and secluded beaches as well as 2 private, well manicured parks. Great amenities in town including tennis, sailing, outdoor yoga, sunbathing, plus nice restaurants. Pedestrian and dog friendly town; you don't even need a car while here.

Guest favourite
A charming cottage exterior is surrounded by lush greenery and autumn foliage. The two-story structure features a balcony adorned with potted plants. Large windows create a welcoming appearance, while the grassy area in front offers a peaceful outdoor setting.
Guesthouse in Wilton
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

The Cozy Little Cottage

Charming guest apartment on our property on 1.5 acres in pastoral neighborhood, 7 minutes to Wilton center and 8 to Westport center. The cottage is a good size for 1-2 adults, can fit 3 people if one is a child. The unit is separate from our house, connected by a breezeway, above the garage. It is quaint and cozy. High end kitchen appliances include gas range, mini fridge, microwave and mini dishwasher. The bedroom has a queen bed. We have a twin air mattress for use in the living room.

Top guest favourite
The exterior of a bright red carriage house is surrounded by lush gardens filled with various flowers and greenery. Two large windows and a white door are visible, adding charm to the traditional New England design. A well-maintained lawn complements the vibrant landscape.
Guesthouse in Wallingford
5 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

The Garden Loft - A Charming Choate Stay

Welcome to The Garden Loft! Located in the heart of downtown Wallingford, CT. This traditional and historic New England carriage house has been completely renovated in the summer of 2022 into a peaceful, cozy, bright & airy loft. We are a 3 minute walk from downtown where you will find a variety of restaurants, bars, a brewery & only 1 mile from from Choate Rosemary Hall. A 15 minute drive to Yale University & downtown New Haven. Get ready to relax, get cozy & enjoy The Garden Loft!

Top guest favourite
The exterior of the guest house is framed by manicured gardens, featuring two decorative statues positioned beside a pea gravel walkway. A small patio area includes a round table with two chairs, creating a serene spot for outdoor relaxation.
Guesthouse in Waccabuc
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

French Guest House in Waccabuc

A mini Versailles just outside of NYC - located on a private and gated eight acre estate with its own lake in Waccabuc, NY. Surrounded by 18C statuary, manicured gardens and fountains, it’s equivalent to staying in a 5-Star European luxury hotel suite (house designed by David Easton) with its heated stone floors and heated towel rack, luxury linens, gold taps and serene private entrance. (.7mi from Waccabuc Country Club, 60 min from NYC by car or train - Katonah train St)

Top guest favourite
A sunlit open space features a light-colored wooden floor and white walls. Two large windows invite natural light, while a patterned area rug adds warmth. A small table and chairs are arranged nearby, creating a versatile area for dining or work.
Guesthouse in Cold Spring
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 189 reviews

Modern+bright forest escape - near village & train

Modern, efficient, and elegant private flexible garden apt. Guesthouse can be used as a studio apartment, or as a private personal retreat space for art/work/rest/meditation. Hiking trails available right out the door, and just a few minutes walk to Cold Spring's vibrant Main Street and Metro North train station to NYC and beyond. Comfortable bed, all modern amenities. Private patio. Native pollinator gardens and forest surround. Solar orientation brings in natural light.

Guest favourite
The cottage is nestled among lush trees, highlighted by a distinctive stone chimney. Expansive glass doors reflect the surrounding greenery, inviting natural light inside. The structure is surrounded by verdant shrubs, creating a harmonious connection with nature.
Guesthouse in Pound Ridge
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 98 reviews

A Lovely Cottage in the Woods

Welcome to our cottage located just 1 hour north of NYC! It is nestled into 2.7 acres of beautiful gardens, mossy groves, and lovely woods. Nature abounds: The property abuts the 4000 acres of the Ward Pound Ridge Reservation. A trailhead begins right across the driveway. The cottage is equipped with a stone fireplace, spacious kitchen, living room area, table for dining and working, and a sleeping loft. During the summer, a private salt water pool is available.

Top guest favourite
A spiral staircase with a sleek black railing leads to the loft bedroom. A mirror with a burgundy frame is mounted against the wall, reflecting the light. The open living area features a light-colored couch and a wooden dining table, visible through large windows offering views of the outdoors.
Guesthouse in Mystic
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 655 reviews

Gorgeous Waterfront Getaway

Perfect getaway from the city for couples wanting peace and tranquility and stunning views. A beautiful waterfront one bedroom guesthouse, one and one-half miles from downtown Mystic CT. Beautifully decorated with art and antiques. Kitchenette, full bath and loft bedroom. Queen bed. Air conditioning and heated. Belgian linen bedding! Private patio. Dock. Kayak/Canoe rentals close by. Internet.

Guest favourite
A cozy living area is highlighted by a spacious sofa adorned with a soft throw, accompanied by a wooden coffee table. Natural light streams through large windows, illuminating a rustic fireplace and a decorative sculpture. Bookshelves filled with various books create an inviting atmosphere.
Guesthouse in Mystic
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 302 reviews

True Artist Loft, 5 minutes to downtown Mystic

A Historic Artist’s Retreat Near Downtown Mystic Lovingly known as The Dacha for nearly 80 years, this one-of-a-kind gem was built in 1945 as a studio for the artist who once called the property home. Fully insulated for cozy winter stays, the unique structure is tucked away on a peaceful piece of land, just five minutes from downtown Mystic.

Guest favourite
A comfortable living area is featured, showcasing a brown sofa with colorful pillows and a small table. Large windows are adorned with checkered curtains, allowing natural light to fill the room. A light fixture hangs above a blue cabinet, adding a touch of charm.
Guesthouse in Sayville
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 212 reviews

Great South Bay Cottage

Fantastic private cottage on Long Island's South Shore. Great access to the best beaches in the world (walk to bay, ferries to ocean). Short train ride to/from NYC, Wineries & The Hampton's. Experience the Island’s charm and culture. Enjoy Long Island summers. We employ a professional cleaning regiment.

Top guest favourite
Guesthouse in Southport
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 204 reviews

Southport, CT across from BEACH

Located at Southport beach on Westport Line, this renovated 1 bedroom apartment totally private located above the garage and includes a full kitchen with new appliance and d/w and central air. Bdrm with queen, fine cotton sheets and towels, marble bath open living room w views.

Guest favourite
A private brick patio is depicted, featuring a round table with four white plastic chairs beneath a floral umbrella. Potted plants adorn the space, and a striped chair is positioned nearby, creating an inviting outdoor setting.
Guesthouse in East Meadow
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 167 reviews

Petite Cottage

Petite Cottage is quiet yet convenient to beautiful Long Island Beaches, North Fork Vineyards, South Fork, The Hampton's and fine eateries. Close to the excitement of Manhattan's Broadway Shows, Fine Dining, Central Park, Museums and Galleries.

Popular amenities for Fire Island guesthouses

Quick stats about guesthouse rentals in Fire Island

  • Total rentals

    30 properties

  • Nightly prices starting at

    $126 CAD before taxes and fees

  • Total number of reviews

    1.3K reviews

  • Pet-friendly rentals

    10 properties allow pets

  • Rentals with a pool

    10 properties have a pool

  • Rentals with dedicated workspaces

    20 properties have a dedicated workspace

Destinations to explore