Vacation rentals in Fish Creek

We had a wonderful long weekend in this super cozy, extremely clean home where we had everything we needed. The view and sunsets were amazing, and we enjoyed the backyard even though the weather was a little chilly. Check in was easy and Natasha was very responsive. We would definitely recommend staying here and would love to come back again!

Loved the big beautiful window looking onto the lake!

We truly enjoyed our weekend, the house had everything we needed and the surroundings were picturesque and welcoming. We are looking forward to returning with the family during the summer months.

Tricia's Sister Bay condo was the PERFECT place to stay in Door County. It was so comfortable, clean and close to everything you would want to do. Beyond the condo itself, Tricia was INCREDIBLY quick to respond and help us with any questions. We booked her place very last minute because another reservation ended up in a disaster and we had to quickly rebooked. Within minutes she turned around the information we needed and got us checked in and comfortable. I can't recommend her highly enough.

We had a terrible start to our holiday, and needed a last minute change from our original house. Found this place and contacted Rob, who responded immediately and set us up with the most beautiful, peaceful home. Everything was perfect. The heated floors, fire pit and well stocked kitchen made our family Christmas exactly what we needed. Would absolutely stay again!

This place was delightful , very comfortable, beautiful surroundings, right on Lake Michigan with all the comforts of home. The beds and bedding were very comfortable. Kitchen well stocked. Bathrooms very clean. Plenty of space and room. Overall it was very clean and tidy too. The location is close to towns and places for whatever you want to do such as shopping or getting into a nature park and trail. I was there in the fall and the colors were fantastic but this is a great place for any season.

One of the best places I’ve stayed in. You can tell there is great attention to making this place exceed expectations. From the comfortable mattresses, soft sheets and the cozy living room set up, etc. you can tell it was intended to make guests feel comfortable and at-home. The cleanliness of this place was next level. Saving for future Door County stays!

Beautiful place, wonderful hosts

This is a great peaceful and very private place to stay. We feel very welcome and right at home staying here. The owners have been great and the cabin is so very well stocked with everything you could want or need.