Vacation rentals in Forsyth

Fisher Farm~a restored farmhouse in wine country!

"Welcome to Fisher Farm, a working grape farm that has been in the Fisher Family for 65 years! Located in the middle of the wine trail in Chautauqua County, NY, this home is located just minutes away from the Shortman Road Exit on I90. Our central location provides you access to over 20 wineries and distilleries, Lake Chautauqua, Lake Erie, and access for skiing, boating, hunting, fishing, kayaking, hiking, biking, and world class sunsets. Buffalo, Erie and Cleveland are just short day trips!

Jubilee Treehouse-Elevated Hot tub, Fireplace

There is something special about being up in the trees, surrounded by nature. In this cozy, little treehouse, you will find that no detail has been overlooked. Enjoy the forest view where it’s likely you'll see wild deer or turkey. Build a fire in the fire pit, have a stargazing soak in the hot tub, enjoy the freedom of an outdoor shower (available May 1- Oct 25), or relax on the hammock deck. You’ll have everything you need for the perfect getaway. Once you arrive, you won't ever want to leave.

Kelly Cottage

Comfort and convenience put you within walking distance to Barcelona Harbor and it’s historic lighthouse and centrally located on the Lake Erie Wine trail. Visit many art galleries and studios and attend various festivals throughout the year. For fishermen, opportunities include world class creeks for fly fishing and many charter boats for walleye excursions. Bring your bass boat, as we have plenty of parking. Chautauqua Institution is 15 minutes away. Guys or gals weekend groups welcome

The Fisherman's Cottage - a Lakeside Loft

A cozy retreat in the heart of the Lake Erie Wine Trail that comes with a complimentary wine tasting. This newly renovated 1950's fishing cabin boasts modern amenities to ensure your comfort while retaining hints of it's former purpose. Wake up each morning to take in the panoramic view of Lake Erie from the back deck. Enjoy sunset from the screened in porch while you listen to the waves below. The Fisherman's Cottage is perfect for a girl's weekend at the wineries or a romantic getaway.

Your Home Away from Home with No worries at all

Welcome and make yourselves at home. Located in the quaint little village of Mayville. Fully furnished in traditional decor. Chautauqua Lake is a mile away with a Public Boat launch & dock. Nearby things to do include hiking, biking, swimming, canoeing, fishing, golf, museums, and all kinds of shopping. Cleanliness has always been one of our top priorities. Due to COVID-19, our cleaning service has initiated an enhanced cleaning routine and are taking extra care to disinfect our home.

Lake Front Home Near Peek'n Peak

Welcome to Captains' Quarters. Beautiful lake front home, literally on the water. Open and enclosed deck with incredible lake views. Large dock on the water, swimming ramp, fire pit, and outdoor dining space. Wood burning fireplace, perfect for winter fun. Enjoy all 4 seasons. Fishing, two kayaks and a paddle boat, and boat rental available during summer. Visit Peek n Peak, less than 10 minutes away, with golf, adventure park (zip lines, mini golf & ropes course), spa, downhill skiing.

1 Bedroom Apt on the Lake Erie Wine Trail

Newly renovated upstairs apartment featuring all new floors, fixtures and appliances. Fully equipped kitchen, comfortable queen size bed. New furniture and 50 inch smart tv. Wifi is available. Very clean and very private. Parking available for vehicle and boat trailer if needed. Great space for fishermen or hunters, but cozy enough for a weekend private getaway for a couple to reconnect. Close to wineries, Lake Erie shore and marina, Peek and Peak Resort and great restaurants.

Blue Canoe/Upscale Lake Cottage/Chautauqua

Welcome to Blue Canoe Lake Cottage on Cassadaga Lakes! This small, 2 Queen Bedroom/1 Full Bath, newly renovated, open-concept, light-filled cottage offers 125 ft of private waterfront, a gated covered porch, & thoughtful details throughout. Enjoy 2 kayaks, 2 paddle boards, a pedal boat, 4 adult cruiser bikes, fire pit, & propane grill. Dog-friendly & perfect for up to 4 adults — luxury on the lake awaits! If booked, check out our sister property, Blue Oar (4BR/3BA, lakefront!

Sunset Lake Cabin

Newly Renovated! The Sunset Lake Cabin is a beautiful chalet style cabin on a beautiful piece of lakefront property and nestled in the woods. It has a little bit of everything, towering pine trees, amazing lake views and a very quiet relaxing atmosphere. Natural beautiful wood throughout. You’ll think you’re in Napa Valley. Open floor plan sleeping with loft bunks overlooking two story stone fireplace and antler chandelier. Open floor plan sleeps 10.

Beachfront Cottage w/Amazing Views! Sunset Cottage

Come visit us at Steelhead Run offering panoramic views of the sunsets on Lake Erie. You will find this Two-bedroom cottage to be quite comfortable offering all the utility of a smaller home. When you arrive, you will find yourself nestled between Lake Erie and Chautauqua Creek on 7 forested acres with access to Lake Erie. On the beach you can spend time hunting for beach glass and driftwood, or take the half-mile walk along the beach to Barcelona Harbor.

North East Cottage on Lake Erie

Getaway from the busy world and enjoy the captivating shores of Lake Erie. With a few steps out the door, your toes will be on the sand. Our charming cottage will give you a revitalizing taste of lakeside living. (Just know lately the water levels have been very high so the beach area varies by day) Feel comfortable and relax knowing everything in the private cottage has been recently updated, new furniture, linens & carpet.

Westfield Charmer

Charming 2 Bedroom/1 Bath home that has been totally remodeled. Brand new kitchen, appliances, floors, furniture, and more! Home has an open concept kitchen-living room, large bedrooms, huge deck with dining table and extra seating. There is an additional folding single bed if needed in MBR closet. Gas grill. Almost 1/2 acre backyard. Well behaved pets are welcome as are children.