Skip to content

Island vacation rentals in New York

Find and book unique island rentals on Airbnb

When results are available, navigate with up and down arrow keys or explore by touch or swipe gestures.

Top-rated island rentals in New York

Guests agree: these island rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Guest favourite
Bungalow in Greig
The Stabbin Cabin Grant Island w/Boat, HotTub, Pet
Welcome to the Grant Island Stabbin Cabin on Brantingham Lake. The Stabbin Cabin is a unique private bungalow on Grant Island with a hammock and chairs in front of the Cabin Hot Tub is steps away for relaxation! We rent Jetski, ATV and Boats. As a guest you will get 30% discount. You get a private electric motorboat for transportation included. Pet Friendly, Wifi, Netflix, Games Access to all Grant Island amenities like diving board, hammocks, docks, workout area, rowboats, canoes etc
Guest favourite
Island in Pine Plains
Magical Private Island Retreat in Pine Plains
Enjoy the serenity of Twin Island Lake, surrounded by tranquil water, lush mountains and nature. this incredible private island retreat is only 2 hours from NYC. Take a canoe across a lily pad dotted lake to your own private island paradise. You will never find a magical space like this so close! The entire island is yours to enjoy and has plenty of outdoor spaces including a propane grill, hammocks and plenty of seating areas. The inside a humble aesthetic with wood paneling and charm.
Island in Clayton
Island Boat House - Fisher's Landing, NY
The Island Boat House is on a private 2 acre island in the 1000 Islands near Fisher's Landing, NY. You may bring or rent a boat, or we can pick you up in our boat for a small fee. This rustic & charming two bedroom living space has a double & queen bed in the main room with a double bed in a separate room. An historic boathouse over the water, guests enjoy a private deck, with shower, dock & grill downstairs. Enjoy the majesty of the St. Lawrence River - fishing, swimming and sunsets galore!

Popular amenities for New York island rentals

Family-friendly island rentals

Home in Southold
Shorecrest Beach House, N Fork, LI
Home in Clayton
Beautiful Waterfront House
Island in Clayton
Island Boat House - Fisher's Landing, NY
Guest favourite
Cabin in Kortright
Lake LaFever Log Estate Luxury Lakefront w Boats
Guest favourite
Cottage in Fishers Landing
The Sea Angell ~ Private Island & Pet Friendly
Guest favourite
Cabin in Paul Smiths
Mrs. Otis's Cabin with Woodland View
Guest favourite
Island in Chippewa Bay
Oak Island in Chippewa Bay NE of Alexandria Bay
Island in Alexandria Bay
Private Island,Millionaires Row,Spa, Stellar Views

Destinations to explore