Vacation rentals in Protestant Cay

Blackbeard's Rendezvous - Downtown Danish Villa

The Bonney, a gated historical Danish villa, rests in the heart of downtown Christiansted! Just 0.2 miles from the Christiansted Boardwalk and walking distance to the ferry, seaplane, shops, bars & restaurants, waterfront, national parks and historic sites. This beautiful 1-bed, 1-bath suite provides AC, WiFi, smart TVs, and a fully equipped kitchen. Access to snorkel gear, beach chairs, umbrellas, coolers, and all your beach needs! Enjoy everything St Croix has to offer in comfort and safety!

Frigates View

This secluded mountainside oasis, conveniently located mid-island, provides panoramic views of Salt River Bay, Buck Island and surrounding islands. A spacious studio with private veranda and separate entry off a verdant courtyard adorned with exotic flora, offers a stunning 180 degree ocean seascape. Enjoy beautifully landscaped grounds, Japanese gazebo and jacuzzi, while listening to the sounds of the breaking surf and cooled by constant trade winds. A perfect blend of romance and relaxation .

Moko Jumbie House - Historic Suite

Experience a unique piece of St. Croix history at the Moko Jumbie House. Once the Danish Armory, this renovated 200-year-old property features original yellow Danish bricks, a grand curved staircase, and preserved old pine floors. Now a 4-unit Airbnb, The Moko Jumbie House reflects the architectural beauty of early 19th-century Christiansted. Just outside, you’ll also find The Guardians, a striking sculpture by Ward Tomlinson Elicker, permanently displayed in tribute to local art and culture.

"Cozy Rooster" Artsy Studio Downtown Christiansted

An eight‑minute walk brings you to the beach, the lively boardwalk, fine dining, art galleries, and the historic attractions of downtown Christiansted. Steeped in history, this charming residence rests in the heart of Christiansted’s Historic Downtown, featured in Henry Morton: St. Croix, St. Thomas, St. John: Danish West Indian Sketchbook and Diary 1843–44. Adding to its character, the home carries a personal story—once in the 1950s, it was home to the great‑grandmother of the current owner.

Come Stay at Schooner Bay!

This condo has it all-great location, AC throughout, sea views & so much more. It has 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a kitchen with stainless steel appliances, a washer & dryer, and a spacious living/dining room area. Relax on the gallery overlooking the Harbor. The complex has 2 pools, a tennis court, night security and an automatic generator. Located just minutes from Christiansted, there are restaurants, a coffee shop, a grocery store, beaches, and a bank within walking distance from the condo.

Luxury Poolside Suite with Harbor Views | Apt 6

Luxury Poolside Suite with Harbor Views | Oasis Luxury Villas STX Experience elevated Caribbean living in this newly renovated luxury poolside apartment overlooking Christiansted Harbor, Buck Island, and Green Cay. Located within a private gated estate on Princesse Hill, this exclusive retreat offers the perfect balance of privacy, comfort, and convenience—just minutes from beaches, restaurants, and downtown Christiansted. Wake each morning to breathtaking sunrise views over the harbor.

Luxury Beachfront Condo with Pool and Hot Tub

One of the best places on St Croix! You are steps from our beach, pool and hot tub, with amazing views from inside and our balcony. Everything is new with luxury finishes! Gorgeous kitchen with quartz counters and new appliances. You get a beautiful bathroom, an amazing bedroom with a new bed, the 55" TV with 50 DVDs and those amazing views! Centrally located to enjoy Buck Island, Hotel on the Cay, Cane Bay beach and Rainbow beach, restaurants, and more. You will love it!

Private Cottage Retreat, Giant Bathroom, Yoga Den

Welcome to your tropical retreat! This brand-new 1-bed, 1-bath guesthouse + bonus yoga room and private patio is your perfect island escape. Nestled in the heart of St. Croix, this spacious getaway offers modern amenities with beautiful outdoor spaces for ultimate relaxation. Centrally located and just 1.7 miles from the Christiansted boardwalk, it’s perfect for exploring beaches, shops, and dining. Unwind or stay active—this cozy retreat brings you the best of the Caribbean.

Sailor's Rest, a Romantic and Luxurious Sanctuary

The real luxury of Sailor's Rest stems from the exclusivity of its location. nestled into the hillside overlooking Salt River Bay, the views and the privacy are unparalleled. Only the pool is shared with me in the main house, but I always give my guests full use and privacy, so it will seem like it is yours alone. I understand how important your vacation is and will always go the extra mile to ensure your stay delivers the luxury and serenity you deserve.

Caribbean Splendor With Million Dollar Views

Welcome to Villa Tortuga! Tortuga means "turtle" in Spanish. This lovely home sits on just under an acre of lush, tropical paradise. Brilliant flamboyant trees and sea views greet you as you enter through the gate. This private, serene home sits high on a hill in a well established neighborhood known as Estate Beeston Hill. It's surrounded by lush, tropical flora with sea and hillside views. Villa Tortuga is only 5 minutes to downtown Christiansted.

St. Croix Ocean Vista Honeymoon Cottage - Beach

1B/1B oceanfront cottage with a full kitchen sits in a gated community on St. Croix's north shore. Featured on HGTV's House Hunters International. 50 steps to the beach. Incredible sun and moon rises over the water. The cottage has battery backup so you will not be bothered by the numerous island power outages. The neighborhood borders the National Park near Salt River Bay. This is a non-smoking property.

Historic Apt in the Heart of Christiansted

An oasis in the center of the action our apt located in the heart of historic downtown Christiansted. Taxi stand, bars and restaurants are all right outside your door! Visit the beach at Hotel on the Cay, only 2 blocks away! The apartment has two bedrooms, the master has a queen size bed and is air conditioned. The second bedroom has two full size beds and is now air conditioned.