Hotel vacation rentals in Lake Montauk

Clean and close to everything. The townhouse was especially roomy

This was a very easy location to get to, and the price was very good. It was everything I needed for a short trip to the Island.

Very clean place the property was quiet and kept up. Friendly staff with great recommendations. Would definitely stay there again.

Kind staffs and clean place to stay!

Great studio apartment!! Very clean and comfortable and tastefully decorated. Joe was extremely communicative. Right on the water and we enjoyed sitting on the outside furniture. It is a very short ride to the lighthouse and downtown Montauk. A beautiful place! We would love to return someday.

Great little hotel! Lots of public spaces. Free books. Great snacks and drinks. Friendly check in staff! Recommend 100%

This is the best location on this side of the north fork. Unbeatable proximity to the beach. The bed is also big and comfortable. Matter of fact the whole room is large. It could use some upgrades but it has those two most important things. Oh! And good food on site! It’s also close to town and to 67 step beach. I will definitely be back in the warmer weather!

So much fun for our entire family. We loved the location & relaxing atmosphere. The housekeeping setup on line was very easy to do & delivery of linens was perfect. Thanku for a great stay

This is a great place to stay at if you are traveling to Long Island. Quiet, clean, and personnel at the front desk are really friendly. The LIRR is close making it easy to travel to NYC. 100% recommend.

We booked here for a little 'staycation' for our first wedding anniversary! The weather wasn't great, but it worked to our advantage and we got an upgrade :) The ladies at the front were very kind and welcoming. The location is perfect right off the ferry and in the main village, walking distance to everything. We would definitely stay here again!!

Very peaceful stay, quiet area but close enough to the Mohegan Sun to enjoy the Casino & concerts. The staff was so friendly & accommodating. We would definitely stay here again. It’s a perfect getaway for couples looking for some quiet time

Had a great stay. Everything was very easy and automated.

My reservation at Wavecrest Resort was one of the most beautiful stays I’ve ever had! The pictures provided in the listing do not do the property justice! Also, the staff was very friendly and helpful, and the studio came with everything we need! All cooking utensils, plates, bowls and cups, a burner plate, hair dryer and the most gorgeous views! The tv also comes with all your favorite apps loaded and ready to play! Overall, I would 1000% recommend booking the Wavecrest Resort for your next stay! :)

What a hidden gem. Whoever designed and decorated this surf shack was a genius. My daughter and I had the best stay!!!

The place was super cute! The staff were always very friendly as we entered and left the place. It was only a block away from the beach!

We had a couple wonderful days in Mystic at the cottage. This is one of the best experiences with airbnb that I have had. A great location and a wonderfully designed space. Herman was one of the nicest dogs too. I would go back to to see him ;)

Friendly staff great location a short walk from a great neighborhood and the beds were comfortable

This was my second stay- this is a favorite spot for me now! I love the decor and feel of this hotel. The staff is very friendly, the location is perfect for walks to the beach, coffee (Queen of Cups) or restaurants (Boon Town, Crazy Burger). We had something happen before our stay and the staff left a very thoughtful note for us when we arrived. Room was comfy and cute. My husband and I read on the back deck and enjoyed the sunshine. We haven’t eaten at the restaurant but we hear the food is fantastic- next time! We highly recommend this spot!