Vacation rentals with lake access in Lake Montauk

Our stay at "The Answer" was perfect. We booked spontaneously during our east coast roadtrip and arrived just a few hours after we booked. We immediately received confirmation and instructions on how to enter the house. From the first moment you could tell that the house has been furnished with the utmost care to detail and a big loving heart. We felt right at home and could not have been happier. From the well equipped kitchen, over the lovely outdoors, to the super cozy living room and bedroom, we could not have felt more welcomed and homey. Big thanks to the hosts. We would stay with you in a heartbeat! Only sad part was that we had to leave so soon and that we didn't get to meet them. Fully recommend!

This was a fabulous destination! We were looking for a big place to have a special anniversary party weekend with extended family, and this house had everything we needed. Plenty of bedrooms upstairs and first floor, many common gathering areas, large kitchen and dining room tables, and lots of Space. (And this doesn't even include the explorable property outside.) The dozens of photos in the listing were very helpful, as well as the detailed descriptions. We had specific needs for elderly relatives with disabilities, and owner Lynne was so responsive in her replies to my many messages with varied questions. Truly, Lynne, you deserve a gold star from Airbnb for promptness and offering up ways and help that made our stay both easier and fulfilling.

The place was amazing! The pictures don’t do justice to the place. We loved staying at this home. We visited the area for a cousins wedding. Perfect for the family. Super clean and the home had a lot to offer!

The house was as beautiful as it looked on the site. It has to be one of the most thoughtful houses that we've stayed at. The house was clean, well stocked, and had plenty of soaps, towels, etc. Arthur was easy to reach and very helpful.

Darren's place is great! Beautiful location, with amazing sunset views. Interior is so nice and bright. We had a lovely stay.

Wonderful house, perfect for our team! Thank you Kelly !

We stayed here for a tattoo convention at Mohegan Sun for work and I can’t say enough good things about this house! It easily accommodated our group and was very spacious and clean. Mitchell was responsive and super easy to talk to when making arrangements! Would definitely come back to this house for future conventions or to visit the area.

This place was a great stay! spotless just like the pictures, a beautiful view where we got the chance to see a wonderful sunset! Instructions were clear and my family had a great time!

We had an amazing stay! Beautiful condo the decor is spotless & the outdoor deck is a huge bonus. Watching the sunset or having coffee in the morning really lade the stay even more relaxing. I cant wait to go back. :)

The place was very clean and comfortable. The amenities were great - there was coffee and supplies for it as well as some bottle water in the fridge. The place was quiet and clean and in a good location. Sean communicated well with us and we had a nice time.

This was our 2nd stay at Andrea’s place. Very peaceful and convenient location for our visits to Connecticut. We come to visit family but the small river towns like Deep River offer much to do and excellent restaurants to boot. We highly recommend Andreas property!

Margie’s place is an amazing hidden gem. The inside is very clean and comfortable. The outside is an experience of its own. The lake will drop your blood pressure immediately. Gorgeous surroundings. The dogs are friendly and lovable. We will be back! 👍🏼

A very accurate listing with a super helpful host. This was our first time using Air BnB and I was a little nervous. Everything was beyond my expectations! Listing was exactly as pictured and described. Host was very explicit with self-check in instructions, guest instructions, etc. We are very familiar with the area but never stayed in Matunuck before. Beautiful and very chill vibes! Thank you so much!

My friend and I stayed at Clare’s Airbnb in Montauk over the weekend, and she was one the nicest and most attentive hosts we have stayed with. Our room was really nice and contained everything we needed to have a very comfortable time. We really appreciated Clare for her very friendly hospitality and for going above and beyond for us whenever we needed her for something. And she was so lovely to our dog, Chi Chi ☺️ We will def stay at her place again if we make another visit to Montauk! 🐶🐾💕

We had a very enjoyable time in the apartment. Everything was as described. Would come back without hesitation.

Amazing views! Beach. Glamping. Camp store and great pizza place.

I can’t say enough about Vicky and Rick‘s place. Not only is it the cutest little cottage on the water, but it is in a great location and a perfect little neighborhood. The house has all the amenities needed. All instructions for everything were very laid out. It was clean and modern, but with a vintage feel. The bedroom is amazing with all around windows and a great view of the water. I would definitely come back here again perhaps in the fall or summer. Highly recommended!

We had a beautiful stay at the cabin. The views are stunning and the hot tub was glorious. A lovely escape into nature.

This is a very well equipped house with 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms all on one level - something hard to find. Dana was exceptionally professional and responsive. The neighborhood is super quiet and only a few blocks walk to the small beach on the Narrow River. We kayaked almost daily! The local RI beaches are spectacular and the biking is also great. The house and environs met all our expectations. We highly recommend this property and Dana and hope to return again!

The place was perfect for us as a weekend getaway: at such peaceful and secluded location, you can really unplug and feel the warmth of the sun and wind from the ocean. Elizabeth was a super responsible and supportive host. Make sure to book if you are looking for a nice vacation at the beach!

What a beautiful weekend in a beautiful, cozy space! We felt immediately at home. The view from the cottage is even more stunning than the pictures. You can tell Donna really cares about this space by all the little touches and details. It was spotlessly clean and the couch is so comfortable! We loved sitting out on the deck by the fire pit and enjoying the fall foliage. Nearby Chester, CT was a trip highlight for us as well. We’d love to make a repeat visit!

Amazing stay this weekend at Leann’s place!! Felt right at home & the place was fully stocked with literally everything we could need, she even left us some eggs in the fridge for breakfast! Perfect location, easy to follow instructions, very clean, super responsive! First time stay in RI was everything we could’ve needed for winter wellness weekend. Hope to be back in summer!

Great little bungalow in a wonderful location. We stayed in January but I imagine it to be a bustling little community in the summer season! We can’t wait to checking it out then! The space is very clean with all that is needed for a comfortable stay. Kathy was very kind and communicated extremely well prior to and during our stay. Highly recommend staying here!

We had a great stay at Greg's place. Potter pond is gorgeous and a kayaking paradise, and the walk to the beach was amazing. Being so close to great restaurants was also amazing. This is a gem of a location for a beach vacation. One note- I had thought we'd be able to launch our kayak at the water right behind the unit, but you need to walk them a little bit over to the kayak launch. Not a big deal, but make sure you bring a kayak cart if you think you'll need one.